What Are the Best Pizza Restaurants in North Myrtle Beach, SC?
A local's guide to the best pizza in North Myrtle Beach — from NY-style slices to neighborhood favorites
By Cathy Cagno | North Myrtle Beach Real Estate
Life in North Myrtle Beach has a natural rhythm to it — beach days, waterfront evenings, outdoor everything. But somewhere in that rhythm, there's a Tuesday night when nobody wants to cook, the kids are hungry, and you need something that's fast, satisfying, and won't disappoint. That's where a good pizza spot earns its permanent place in your life.
Pizza isn't glamorous. It doesn't need to be. It just needs to be good, accessible, and reliable — the kind of meal that fixes the evening without any effort. The best pizza restaurants in North Myrtle Beach do exactly that, and the locals who have found their go-to spots are pretty devoted to them.
Cathy Cagno is a real estate agent in North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina helping buyers and sellers who gets asked about everyday conveniences just as often as real estate specifics. Pizza spots come up regularly — especially from families and people relocating from the Northeast who have strong opinions about what a good slice should look like. Here's the honest local guide.
Why Pizza Matters in a Beach Town
Good pizza fills a specific and important role in daily life — especially in a community like North Myrtle Beach where the lifestyle is active and outdoor-focused. You need meals that work around everything else.
A solid pizza spot means easy takeout after a long beach day when cooking isn't happening. It means a family dinner that everyone agrees on without a negotiation. It means delivery on a rainy evening when the couch is where you're staying. These things matter more than people admit, and a community with reliable pizza options is a community that works for full-time living.
The spots on this list have earned their place in the local rotation for exactly these reasons.
The Best Pizza in North Myrtle Beach, SC
All of the restaurants below are located within North Myrtle Beach. These are the spots that come up when locals talk about where they actually go for pizza.
Main Street Area
Sarabella’s Pizzeria
Main Street, NMB | Classic Pizzeria | Dine-In and Takeout Local Favorite
Sarabella’s Pizzeria on Main Street has built a genuine local following that keeps it full on weeknights and weekends alike. The pizza is made with care — proper dough, quality toppings, and the kind of consistent execution that makes it a reliable answer every time someone asks where to go. It’s the kind of neighborhood pizzeria that a community earns after enough time, and North Myrtle Beach residents who have found it tend to stay loyal. A true Main Street staple.
Ocean Plaza on Main Street
Daniello’s Pizzeria & Pub
Ocean Plaza, Main Street NMB | Small and Quaint Local Pizzeria and Pub | Dine-In Gem
Daniello’s is the kind of small, quaint local spot that people who live in North Myrtle Beach quietly treasure. Tucked into Ocean Plaza on Main Street, it has the intimate feel of a neighborhood pizzeria and pub that you stumble onto once and then keep coming back to. The pizza is the draw, but the pub atmosphere and the relaxed local vibe make it more than just a quick meal. It’s the kind of place that earns real loyalty — the sort of spot you introduce to every new person who moves to the area.
Giorgio’s Famous Pizza
Main Street, NMB | Famous for a Reason | Dine-In and Takeout
The word “famous” in a restaurant name is usually just marketing — but Giorgio’s has the local following to back it up. The pizza here has earned a strong reputation on Main Street for good reason: it’s consistently well-made, the flavors are right, and the portions are generous. Locals recommend it without hesitation, and it comes up regularly in conversations about where to go for a genuinely good pizza in North Myrtle Beach. The name isn’t a boast — it’s a track record.
Highway 17 Corridor
Gino’s NY Style Pizzeria
Highway 17, NMB | Authentic NY-Style Pizza | The Real Deal for Slice Lovers
If you grew up on New York-style pizza and have strong opinions about what a proper slice should taste like, Gino’s is the answer on Highway 17. Thin, foldable, properly sauced, and made the way it’s supposed to be — not a coastal approximation of NY pizza but the real thing done right. Locals who relocated from the Northeast tend to find this one fast and hold onto it. It fills a specific craving that a lot of people moving to the area didn’t expect to find this well-covered.
Benito’s Brick Oven Pizza and Pasta
Highway 17, NMB | Brick Oven Pizza and Pasta | Elevated Casual Dining
Benito’s brings brick oven cooking to the Highway 17 corridor and the difference shows up in every pie. The crust has the char and chew that only comes from a proper brick oven, and the pasta menu gives it range beyond just pizza. It’s a step up in quality from the standard takeout options — the kind of spot where dine-in feels worth it — and locals who have discovered it tend to make it a regular. A solid choice when you want pizza that tastes like someone put real thought into making it.
Types of Pizza Experiences in North Myrtle Beach
|
The Pizza Landscape in NMB |
|
NY-style slices — proper crust and classic execution for the slice purists |
|
California-style and specialty pies — creative options beyond the standard menu |
|
Fast-casual build-your-own — quick, fresh, and customizable for busy nights |
|
Dine-in pizza restaurants — sit-down experiences that work for family dinners |
|
Delivery and takeout staples — reliable options for beach nights and rainy evenings |
What the pizza scene in North Myrtle Beach covers is the full range of how people actually use pizza in their lives. Quick delivery on a weeknight, a casual dine-in lunch, a specialty pie for a more intentional meal — there's a spot for each. That kind of everyday accessibility is part of what makes the lifestyle here work for full-time residents.
What This Says About Living in North Myrtle Beach
The quality of a community's casual dining options tells you something real about whether it works for everyday living. North Myrtle Beach isn't just a vacation destination — it's a place where people build real routines, raise families, and need the same practical conveniences as anywhere else.
Having reliable pizza options — delivery, takeout, dine-in, NY-style, specialty — is one of those practical conveniences that sounds small until you're living somewhere that doesn't have it. North Myrtle Beach has it covered, and the locals who've settled here know which spots they can count on.
Cathy Cagno is a real estate agent in North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina helping buyers and sellers understand what living here actually looks like day to day. The dining scene — including where to get a good pizza on a Tuesday night — is part of the picture that matters to people making a serious relocation decision.
Final Thoughts
The best pizza restaurants in North Myrtle Beach, SC cover everything from classic NY-style slices to creative specialty pies to fast-casual build-your-own options. What they share is the kind of consistent quality that turns first-time visitors into regulars.
For anyone thinking about a move to the area, knowing that the everyday convenience of good pizza is covered is one more small but real reason the lifestyle here makes sense for the long term.
As always, verify current hours and delivery areas before you order — but the spots on this list have track records that tend to hold up.
Next Steps
If the North Myrtle Beach lifestyle — the beach, the community, the dining, and the everyday conveniences — sounds like the right fit, let's have a real conversation about what the market looks like and what your options are.
No pressure. Just honest, local guidance from someone who knows this area well.
